Case study: Are indented search results on Google actually hurting your business?

Case study: Are indented search results on Google actually hurting your business?

Most businesses might think having two search results on Page 1 is a good thing. This is not always the case. Here’s why.

Google reinstated indented search results at the end of 2021. Indented search results are when Google shows additional page(s) from the same domain that it thinks are relevant to your query. These usually occur on Page 1.  

Example of indented result

Many people might think having two search results on Page 1 is a good thing, but I will show you why I don’t agree.

Keyword optimization 

As SEO strategists, we are optimizing certain pages to appear for a keyword or query. In the case of indented search results, pages you did not intend to appear are also showing up for that query. 

What if a user clicks on one of the results and doesn’t see what they want? Isn’t this a sign that Google is not sure about which page to show?

CTR based on position 

If we look at these three studies, the average click-through rate (CTR) based on Google SERP position looks like this: 

Position CTR range 
1 28-40%
2 16-18%
3 10-11%
4 7-8%
5 6% or less

Let’s say a website has an indented search result at position 4. Using the table above, our CTR would be around 14% (adding the high of position 4 and position 5).

However, if we could move that search result up to position 2, our CTR would be between 16-18%.

Of course, moving it up to position 1 would be the best with a CTR of 28-40%. 

Can you get Google to remove indented search results?

Yes, you can get indented search results to go away. In the example below, we optimized the top page that was listed in position 5.

However, after we did that, Google started showing an additional page indented between position 5 and position 6. 

Indented search results

So, we went back to the site and ensured the site optimization made it clear which page should rank for that keyword through basic SEO tactics like internal linking.

After doing this, the end result was that the page we wanted to rank moved up to position 4 and the indented search result was gone.

Indented search result removed

What did this do to their traffic?

The month after they moved up from position 5 to position 4, we saw a 55% increase in their traffic on this page.

Rethinking the value of indented search results on SEO

Some people may think that indented search results are a good thing for your website, but I would have to disagree. 

I think it is important to have the page you optimized for a specific keyword be the only page from that domain that shows up for that query. 

Besides the benefits of a higher CTR, we also cannot be assured which page a user would click on if there are two choices. 

I have run into this same scenario with several of our clients in the last few months. In every case I’ve worked on thus far, I found that eliminating the indented result had a positive impact on ranking and traffic to the site. 

Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Search Engine Land. Staff authors are listed here.

Related stories

New on Search Engine Land

    Meta introduces new ad targeting limits for teens

    How marketing compensation and roles are changing: Take the MarTech Salary and Career Survey

    12 new Google Analytics 4 ecommerce dimensions and metrics

    Apple Maps relaunches Apple Business Connect

    Google Business Profiles to stop allowing price ranges on products on February 15

Related Post